This post may contain affiliate links. If you click on these links and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I believe provide value. Thank you.
If you’re trying to decide between the CASABREWS Ultra and the CASABREWS CM5418, I completely understand the confusion. On paper, both machines look very similar. They both promise 20-bar pressure, compact designs, manual milk frothing, and café-style drinks at home without spending Breville money. After spending time with both machines in my kitchen, making everything from straight espresso shots to iced lattes and cappuccinos, I found that they actually feel very different once you start using them every day.
Table of Contents
The CASABREWS Ultra feels like a genuine upgrade that fixes several frustrations I had with the CM5418. While the CASABREWS CM5418 remains one of the best beginner espresso machines under its price range, the Ultra offers better control, better consistency, and a much more enjoyable overall experience.
My Quick Verdict Casabrews cm5418 vs ultra
Buy the CASABREWS Ultra if:
- You want better espresso consistency
- You make milk drinks regularly
- You appreciate adjustable settings
- You want a machine that feels more premium
- You plan on keeping the machine for several years
Buy the CASABREWS CM5418 if:
- You’re on a strict budget
- You’re completely new to espresso
- You mainly drink Americanos or iced coffee
- You want something compact and simple
For most people, I’d spend the extra money and get the Ultra.
CASABREWS Ultra vs CM5418 Specs Comparison
| Feature | CASABREWS Ultra | CASABREWS CM5418 |
|---|---|---|
| Pump Pressure | 20 Bar | 20 Bar |
| Display | LCD Screen | No LCD |
| Temperature Control | Adjustable | Limited |
| Shot Volume Control | Fully Adjustable | Basic Programming |
| Steam Wand | Improved Precision Wand | Standard Steam Wand |
| Water Tank | Larger Capacity | Smaller Capacity |
| Portafilter | 58mm Style Setup | 51mm Portafilter |
| Best For | Enthusiasts & Beginners | First-Time Espresso Users |
First Impressions
The first thing I noticed when unboxing the Ultra was that it felt like CASABREWS actually listened to feedback from previous models. The CM5418 has always looked surprisingly attractive for the price. It has that stainless steel espresso machine appearance that makes your kitchen look more expensive than it really is.
But once I started using it daily, the budget compromises became obvious. The included tamper feels lightweight, the steam wand takes practice, and the machine sometimes feels like it’s working very hard to produce café-quality drinks.
The Ultra immediately felt more refined. The LCD display sounds like a small upgrade, but in real-world use it makes a huge difference. Instead of guessing what the machine is doing, I could see settings clearly and make adjustments without constantly referring back to the manual. It simply felt easier to live with.
Espresso Quality
This is where I spent most of my testing time. For consistency, I used the same medium-roast espresso beans, the same grinder, and similar extraction ratios on both machines.
The CM5418 surprised me. For a budget espresso machine, it can pull genuinely enjoyable espresso shots. The crema is thick, the coffee tastes rich, and beginners can get good results without needing professional barista skills.
The challenge is consistency. One morning I’d get a beautiful shot with balanced sweetness and chocolate notes.The next day, using almost identical settings, the extraction would run faster and taste slightly thinner. That’s not unusual for entry-level espresso machines, but it’s something I noticed repeatedly.
The Ultra produced more reliable results. The adjustable temperature settings helped me dial in different beans more effectively, and shot volume adjustments felt more accurate. I especially noticed the difference when brewing lighter roasted beans.The Ultra extracted more flavor complexity, while the CM5418 sometimes struggled to bring out those subtle notes.
If you’re the type of person who enjoys experimenting with coffee beans, you’ll appreciate the additional control.
Winner: CASABREWS Ultra
Milk Frothing and Latte Performance
I drink lattes almost every day, so steam wand performance matters more to me than marketing claims.
The CASABREWS CM5418 can absolutely make cappuccinos and lattes. However, creating silky microfoam requires patience.The wand sometimes feels underpowered, and I found myself spending extra time stretching and texturing milk to get something suitable for latte art.
Most mornings, the foam was good enough. Not amazing. Just good enough.
The CASABREWS Ultra was noticeably easier to use. I could create smoother milk texture with less effort, and the foam consistency was more predictable. Was it comparable to a high-end Breville machine? No.But for the price range, I was impressed. If milk drinks are your primary reason for buying an espresso machine, the Ultra is the better choice.
Winner: CASABREWS Ultra
Daily Usability
This is where the difference between the two machines becomes obvious. The CASABREWS CM5418feels like a beginner machine.That’s not necessarily a criticism. Everything is simple and straightforward. You just power on and choose a shot. Steam milk. Done.
The CASABREWS Ultra feels more like a machine you’ll grow into.I enjoyed having adjustable shot volumes and temperature settings because it allowed me to fine-tune drinks based on different beans and roast levels.
After several weeks, I found myself reaching for the Ultra more often simply because it made the process more enjoyable.
Build Quality
Neither machine feels like a $1,000 prosumer espresso machine. That’s important to understand. The CM5418 uses more lightweight materials throughout the machine and accessories.The portafilter, tamper, and included tools definitely remind you that this is a budget-friendly espresso setup.
The Ultra still isn’t premium territory, but it feels more substantial overall. Its controls feel better. The interface feels more polished, inspiring more confidence during daily use.
Cleaning and Maintenance
Both machines are relatively easy to maintain. I usually rinse the portafilter immediately after brewing, wipe the steam wand after every use, and run a deeper cleaning cycle weekly. The removable drip trays make cleanup simple. The Ultra gets a slight advantage because the display makes maintenance reminders easier to follow.
Neither machine gave me major headaches when it came to cleaning.
What I Didn’t Like
- Steam wand requires practice
- Included accessories feel cheap
- Espresso consistency can vary
- Smaller portafilter limits upgrade options
- Can vibrate during extraction
- Costs noticeably more
- Still not ideal for advanced latte art
- Some plastic components remain
- No built-in grinder
Who Should Buy the CASABREWS CM5418?
I would recommend the CM5418 if:
- This is your first espresso machine
- You’re upgrading from a pod machine
- Budget matters more than advanced features
- You mainly drink straight espresso or Americanos
It’s one of the few affordable machines I’ve used that can genuinely make enjoyable espresso once you learn its quirks.
Who Should Buy the CASABREWS Ultra?
I would recommend the Ultra if:
- You already know you’ll use the machine daily
- You enjoy lattes and cappuccinos
- You want more control over extraction
- You appreciate better consistency
- You’re willing to spend a little more upfront
The Ultra feels like the machine CASABREWS should have released after learning everything from the CM5418.
Final Verdict: Which One Is Better?
After using both machines side-by-side, I’d choose the CASABREWS Ultra. The CM5418 is still one of the better budget espresso machines I’ve tested. It offers impressive value and makes surprisingly good coffee once you understand its limitations.
But the Ultra feels more complete.The improved controls, more consistent extraction, better steaming experience, and overall refinement make it easier to recommend for most home coffee drinkers.
If the price difference fits your budget, I’d skip the CM5418 and go straight for the Ultra. You’ll likely enjoy the experience more, and you’ll have less temptation to upgrade again six months later.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is the CASABREWS Ultra worth the extra money?
In my experience, yes. The improved temperature control, LCD display, and better milk frothing performance justify the higher price if you make coffee regularly.
- Can the CASABREWS CM5418 make good espresso?
Absolutely. With fresh beans and a decent grinder, the CM5418 can produce surprisingly enjoyable espresso shots for the price.
- Which machine is better for beginners?
The CASABREWS CM5418 is slightly easier for complete beginners because of its simpler controls. However, the Ultra offers more room to grow without becoming overwhelming.
- Do either of these machines have a built-in grinder?
No. You’ll need a separate espresso grinder for the best results.
- Which machine makes better lattes?
The CASABREWS Ultra. Its steam wand is easier to work with and produces smoother milk texture with less effort.